Exploding Kittens | Party card games, puzzles, greeting cards ...

What Were You Thinking?

The Guessing Game For Horrible Mind Readers

What Were You Thinking? - Main image
$12.79 $19.99 In stock

Category: Games

Can you give the perfect clue before anyone else? What Were You Thinking? is a guessing game for horrible mind readers, and it's as fun to watch as it is to play.

Break into two teams. Shuffle the Letter Tiles and place them on The Board until it’s full. Pick one person from each team to be the Guesser. It’s your team’s job to get your Guesser to say the word from the Word Card by giving them a two word clue that starts with letters from The Board. For example, if your word is “Penguin,” your team might decide to give “Snow Bird” as a clue. But hurry, because if the other team yells out a clue first, their Guesser can guess before yours. If they get it right, that team gets to flip over the letters they used for a clue (Ex. if the winning clue is “waddling tuxedo,” they’d flip over “w” and “t”.) The team that flips 5 letters in a row wins.

This family board game makes you flex your creativity to think up unique (or outrageous) clues. But it's also an easy-to-learn and simple-to-play strategy game that's different every time you play. 

What's In the Box?

What Were You Thinking? comes with:

  • 36 Letter Tiles
  • 100 Cards
  • 1 Board

Plus, one instruction manual that you will probably skim.

Game contents with a blue word grid board, cards, and pencils

HEY! READING IS THE WORST WAY TO LEARN HOW TO PLAY A GAME. WATCH THIS INSTEAD:

What Were You Thinking game cooperative and competitive modes

QUICK STEP GUIDE

How to play: a cartoon figure with Penguin and Peanut word cards

PULL

Have one Guesser from each team close their eyes. Then, pull a Word Card for them to guess. 

Poetry for Neanderthals clue card reading Waddling Tuxedo for Penguin

RACE

When the Guessers open their eyes, hurry and think of the perfect two-word clue using letters from the Board before the other team does.

Characters shouting Waddling Tuxedo and Penguin in the spill round

SPILL

Give your clue and hope that it makes sense to the Guesser. 

Letter grid puzzle with an arrow showing the flip transformation

FLIP

If it worked, flip the Tiles on the Grid that correspond with your clue. 

Players celebrating with confetti around a card grid

WIN

The first team to flip 5 in a row wins.

Customer Reviews (4.8 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Amelia ★★★★★

We played this at a family gathering last night, and the way the clues go sideways before anyone guesses right is genuinely hilarious. The two-team setup keeps everyone involved, even the people watching who end up laughing harder than the players.

Ava ★★★★★

The two-team format got everyone shouting over each other within minutes, and shuffling the cards kept rounds feeling fresh even after we played four in a row. Even the worst guessers in our group landed a few hilarious clues, so nobody felt left out.

Emma ★★★★★

We played this at a party last weekend and the two-team format kept everyone engaged even people who usually zone out during games. The part where you have to be a horrible mind reader is genuinely harder than it sounds, and watching teammates guess wrong is half the fun. Definitely a solid buy for