A guessing game for horrible mind readers
What Were You Thinking? is a team-based party game where you give two-word clues to guide your Guesser to a secret word. The twist? Your clue must start with letters on the board, and the other team can steal your guess if they shout a better clue first. It's a fast, funny party game that rewards creative thinking and a little bit of mind-reading.
The game is designed for two teams, making it a great choice for groups. The box says it's for horrible mind readers, but don't worry—you don't need psychic powers to play. You just need to think of clues that are clever, weird, or outrageous enough to stick.
What's in the box
- What Were You Thinking?: 36 Letter Tiles, 100 Cards, 1 Board, and an instruction manual. Knowing the components helps you set up quickly and understand the game's scope.

What Were You Thinking?
How to play, step by step
- Set up the board: Shuffle the Letter Tiles and place them on the board until it's full. Each team picks one person to be the Guesser.
- Pull a word card: Have the Guessers close their eyes. Pull a Word Card for them to guess—keep it hidden from the Guessers.
- Race to give a clue: When the Guessers open their eyes, both teams race to think of a two-word clue that starts with letters on the board. For example, if the word is 'Penguin,' you might say 'Snow Bird.'
- Spill the clue: Give your clue and hope your Guesser gets it. If the other team yells out a clue first, their Guesser can guess before yours.
- Flip the tiles: If your Guesser guesses correctly, flip the Letter Tiles that correspond to the first letters of your clue. For 'waddling tuxedo,' you'd flip 'W' and 'T.'
- Win the game: The first team to flip five Letter Tiles in a row wins.
Why it works for groups
What Were You Thinking? shines with four or more players. Because it's team-based, everyone stays involved—even when it's not their turn to guess. The race to shout a clue keeps energy high, and the two-word limit forces players to be creative and quick.
The game is easy to learn (the manual is short, though the box jokes you'll probably skim it), and it plays differently every time because the clues depend on who's playing. It's a solid choice for adult game nights, but it's also family-friendly—the box doesn't specify an age range, but the content is generally appropriate for older kids and adults.
Who it suits
- What Were You Thinking?: The game is for two teams and involves giving two-word clues. This team format makes it ideal for parties or family gatherings where you want everyone interacting.
- What Were You Thinking?: It's described as an easy-to-learn and simple-to-play strategy game that's different every time. That means it works well for mixed groups of experienced and new players.
What the catalog doesn't tell you
The supplied information doesn't specify a recommended age range or player count beyond 'two teams.' It also doesn't include any safety warnings or care instructions. If you're buying for a younger audience, you may want to check the box or manufacturer's website for age recommendations. But for most adult and teen groups, What Were You Thinking? is a safe bet for a funny, fast-paced party game.


