Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-21 Exploding Kittens | Party card games, puzzles, greeting cards ... 0 views

Catchables 2-Pack: Caterina & Catastrophe vs Donut & Lumber

Catchables 2-Pack: Caterina & Catastrophe vs Donut & Lumber

Compare two Catchables 2-Packs: Caterina & Catastrophe vs Donut & Lumber. See what's inside, how they play, and which squishy kitty duo fits your collection.

Two Squishy Kitty Duos, One Decision

If you're looking for a quick, silly party game under $10, the Exploding Kittens Catchables 2-Packs deliver exactly that. Each pack includes two squishy cats and 24 stunt cards, letting you toss, catch, and collect your way to victory. The question is: which pair should you start with?

Both the Catchables 2-Pack #3 (Caterina & Catastrophe) and the Catchables 2-Pack #1 (Donut & Lumber) share the same gameplay, price point, and expandability. The real difference comes down to character preference and which cats you want in your collection.

Caterina & Catastrophe vs Donut & Lumber: Side-by-Side

Both packs are identical in mechanics and contents. Here's how they compare at a glance.

  • Characters Included: Catchables 2-Pack #3 includes Caterina and Catastrophe. Catchables 2-Pack #1 includes Donut Cat and Lumber Cat.
  • Price: Catchables 2-Pack #3 is $6.59 (compare at $9.99). Catchables 2-Pack #1 is $6.69 (compare at $9.99). Both under $10.
  • What's in the Box: Each pack contains 2 Catchables (squishy cats) and 24 cards. The cards include action stunts and opponent-messing cards.
  • Number of Players: Play with 2 players out of the box. Combine with any other Catchables Pack to add as many players as you like.
  • Gameplay: Pick 4 action cards, throw your Catchable, perform the stunts before catching it (3 tries). If you succeed, deal cards to opponents. First to complete 5 stunts wins.
  • Expandability: Mix and match any Catchables Packs to increase player count and stunt variety.

Same Game, Different Cats

Since both packs play identically, your choice is purely cosmetic. Caterina and Catastrophe offer a quirky duo with a mischievous vibe. Donut and Lumber bring a food-themed cat and a woodsy cat to the table. Neither pack has a gameplay advantage over the other.

If you already own one pack, the other adds two new characters and fresh cards, making the game more chaotic and fun. Collecting multiple packs is the intended way to expand the experience.

Product Facts: What the Catalog Confirms

  • Catchables 2-Pack #3 (Caterina & Catastrophe): Catchables 2-Pack #3 includes Caterina and Catastrophe. Play with 2 players or combine with any other Catchables Pack to add more players. Confirms that this pack is a standalone 2-player game that can be mixed with other packs for larger groups.
    Catchables 2-Pack #3 (Caterina & Catastrophe)
    Catchables 2-Pack #3 (Caterina & Catastrophe)
  • Catchables 2-Pack #1 (Donut & Lumber): Catchables 2-Pack #1 includes Donut Cat and Lumber Cat. Same expandability: combine with any other Catchables Pack. Shows this pack is functionally identical to #3, so the decision is purely about which characters you prefer.
    Catchables 2-Pack #1 (Donut & Lumber)
    Catchables 2-Pack #1 (Donut & Lumber)

Which Pack Should You Buy?

If you're new to Catchables, pick the pack with the characters that make you smile more. Both are under $10, so it's a low-risk entry. If you already have one, grab the other for double the cats and cards.

There is no wrong choice here. The game's fun comes from the stunts and the toss-catch mechanic, not from any specific cat. Either pack will give you a solid, silly party game.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile